Re: Claire Balding & Liam Treadwell
Posted: Thu Apr 09, 2009 6:17 am
It's not about choice it's about consent. The guy at the Polo club whom Prince Charles calls 'Sooty' consents to that because it's difficult ans impolitic to say 'no' to the future King of England.
Nicknames reinforce esprit de corps in the forces and football/ rugby teams etc. There's a difference between that and the situation where if you voice any misgivings about the inappropriateness of a nickname you're merely being thin skinned.
It's about power relationships - ask yourself why it may be acceptable between black people to use the 'N' word, but if it's white to black the dynamic and intent is very different. Look at the Balding/ Treadwell power relationship - Balding's is very advantaged in terms of socio economic background, probably privately educated, university, BBC (which isn't as diverse as it likes to think). Treadwell like most jockeys is probably from a relatively disadvantaged background and so Balding thinks it's okay to inspect his teeth as she would an animal at the county show.
It's not about her giving him a nickname - she didn't - it's about her behaving towards him in such a way that denies him respect and dignity.
Nicknames reinforce esprit de corps in the forces and football/ rugby teams etc. There's a difference between that and the situation where if you voice any misgivings about the inappropriateness of a nickname you're merely being thin skinned.
It's about power relationships - ask yourself why it may be acceptable between black people to use the 'N' word, but if it's white to black the dynamic and intent is very different. Look at the Balding/ Treadwell power relationship - Balding's is very advantaged in terms of socio economic background, probably privately educated, university, BBC (which isn't as diverse as it likes to think). Treadwell like most jockeys is probably from a relatively disadvantaged background and so Balding thinks it's okay to inspect his teeth as she would an animal at the county show.
It's not about her giving him a nickname - she didn't - it's about her behaving towards him in such a way that denies him respect and dignity.