BGAFD Film Reviews

A read-only and searchable archive of posts made to the BGAFD forum from 11/08/2000 to 14/03/2003.
Locked
magoo

BGAFD Film Reviews

Post by magoo »

Where a review is not credited to a particular reviewer is it safe to assume its written by WG or Alec?
woodgnome

Re: BGAFD Film Reviews

Post by woodgnome »

mine are all credited but as to whether the uncredited reviews have been written by alec alone, only one man can say...
alec

Re: BGAFD Film Reviews

Post by alec »

Everyone else gets credited.
buttsie

o/t Re: BGAFD Film Reviews

Post by buttsie »

What difference does it make?No disrespect to WG or Alec
To me the scene breakdown is more important than the review-sounds stupid I know but.....thats why DVDS will ultimately kill videos.


I would swear that Patrick Riley(P R M....N T...I O...D Maybe) has never written a review that actually said this vid is a keeper.
He obviously works for the BBFC if I'm not mistaken and whatever their counterpart is in the USA-the IRS i believe.

On that basis if you bought vids according to 'HIS TASTE'
you would have about 1300 barbi dolls on video.

cheers
B...OZ the O/T continues
magoo

Re: o/t Re: BGAFD Film Reviews

Post by magoo »

Thanks for the answers chaps. Buttsie the reason I asked was that its worth knowing who wrote the review as you then get to know the particular reviewers likes and dislikes and can decide upon how much importance to give to any comments they make. You comments about Riley back up my reasoning. If for example someone with Rileys ignorance about films and girls were to submit a review then I would like to see it credited so I could ignore all future reviews. Likewise I can pay attention to reviews by people with similar tastes to me.
Locked